Our website would like to use cookies to store information on your computer. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but parts of the site will not work as a result. Find out more about how we use cookies.

Login or Register

Powered by
Powered by Novacaster
 
Re: Couple of comments
by Hugo van der Sanden at 14:12 28/05/04 (Forum::Online Communities)
A "language-independent" representation of communicable concepts would be a very handy tool to have

Handy, maybe, but I believe intrinsically impossible - even mathematics is a language, with its own dialects to help obscure meaning.

Language is the medium of thought as well as of communication. To pick a language is to constrain the concepts you can consider and communicate. To pick no language is to throw out thought and communication altogether.

Note also that "language" is not just words; consider a simple image:

To a mathematician, this may be a simple Venn diagram representing a single non-universal set; to someone from Japan it might be a stylised representation of the flag, with overtones of nation, history and the Emperor. The observer cannot avoid imbuing the message with their own knowledge and their very self.

The best we can hope for, I believe, is to develop a language that is richly expressive yet easy to learn; part of my hopes for future software development is to move toward that goal by throwing off the linguistic shackles of a linear stream of words.

Hugo

Attachments...
GIF image (0 K) image
<< The Whole Earth 'Lectronic Lin... Online conference on Understan... >>
View Comments (Flat Mode) Printer Version
Hi scott wright - 19/05
    Re: Hi There is an attachment here Simon - 19/05
       Re: Hi scott wright - 19/05
          Re: Hi Simon - 20/05
             Re: Hi scott wright - 24/05
                Being in and of a community Hugo van der Sanden - 25/05
                   Re: Being in and of a communit... scott wright - 25/05
                   Re: Being in and of a communit... scott wright - 25/05
                      Questionnaire Simon - 25/05
                         Re: Questionnaire scott wright - 25/05
                            Re: Questionnaire Simon - 25/05
                               Re: Questionnaire scott wright - 27/05
                                  Email addresses Simon - 27/05
                                     Re: Email addresses scott wright - 27/05
                                        Re: Email addresses Simon - 28/05
                         Re: Questionnaire Joanna Robson - 9/06
                            Re: Questionnaire Simon - 11/06
                      Re: Being in and of a communit... scott wright - 30/09
                Moderation (and paging Mr Crow... Simon - 25/05
                   Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... scott wright - 25/05
                      Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... Susie Hughes - 25/05
                      Points for the e-envoy office Simon - 25/05
                         Re: Points for the e-envoy off... scott wright - 27/05
                            Word attachments Simon - 27/05
                               Re: Word attachments There is an attachment here scott wright - 27/05
                                  Couple of comments Simon - 27/05
                                     Re: Couple of comments scott wright - 28/05
                                        Go to where the conversation i... Simon - 28/05
                                     Re: Couple of comments There is an attachment here Hugo van der Sanden - 28/05
                                        Re: Couple of comments Simon - 28/05
                                           History of Computers scott wright - 24/06
                                              Re: History of Computers David Crowson - 24/06
                                              Re: History of Computers Simon - 24/06
                                                 ...and the disadvantage, of co... Simon - 24/06
                                                    Re: ...and the disadvantage, o... scott wright - 25/06
                                                       Is that this one? Simon - 25/06
                                                          Re: Is that this one? scott wright - 5/07
                                                 Re: History of Computers scott wright - 25/06
                                                    Hmmm Simon - 25/06
                                                       Re: Hmmm scott wright - 5/07
                                  Moderating Censorship There is an attachment here scott wright - 22/03
                                     Re: Moderating Censorship Simon - 22/03
                                        Re: Moderating Censorship scott wright - 22/03
                                           Re: Moderating Censorship Simon - 23/03
                                              Re: Moderating Censorship scott wright - 23/03
                                                 Re: Moderating Censorship Simon - 23/03
                            Re: Points for the e-envoy off... Simon - 27/05
                      Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... Susie Hughes - 26/05
                         Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... scott wright - 27/05
                   Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... David Crowson - 26/05
                      Re: Moderation (and paging Mr ... David Crowson - 26/05
                         Globalisation... Simon - 27/05
                            Re: Globalisation... David Crowson - 27/05
                               Erk! Simon - 27/05
                                  Re: Erk! David Crowson - 27/05
                                     Re: Erk! David Crowson - 27/05
                                        Disquiet about this in the pas... Simon - 27/05
             Re: Hi scott wright - 16/08
                Re: Hi Simon - 17/08
                   Re: Hi There is an attachment here scott wright - 21/09
                      Houston Simon - 21/09
                         journal access scott wright - 12/10
                            Re: journal access Simon - 12/10