Our website would like to use cookies to store information on your computer. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but parts of the site will not work as a result. Find out more about how we use cookies.

Login or Register

Powered by
Powered by Novacaster
Re: More accurate data (Re: Stonehenge Hidden Landscape Project - Cursus/HeelStone solstitial alignments)
by Simon at 22:43 01/12/11 (Blogs::Simon)
We're operating in an information vacuum - attempting to deduce alignments from a couple of images with no proper georeference data. It's fun, and interesting, but ultimately not very much use.

The image from the 2010 preliminary report at least had OS grid ticks along the margins, the ones overlaid on the Google Earth backdrop I don't trust as much (because I have little confidence in Google Earth's accuracy in the orthorectification of aerial photos).

I do not understand why the project doesn't make available the OS coords of the supposed pits. I look forward to an actual paper being published that might shed some light on this.

Then there's the horizon altitude to consider in each of those directions which could easily affect the angles as pointed out in your comment on Mike's site (sunrise and sunset are not necessarily symmetric about the meridian unless horizon altitude is exactly the same in each direction), the possible viewing locations (at the Heelstone? SE/SW of the Heelstone on each alignment?) and even whether the builders intended a precise or simply a symbolic alignment (the "near enough is good enough" approach).

Finally, I simply don't buy the processional route midpoint theory at all.

<< Samhain/Imbolc Sunrise alignme... Winter Solstice Sunrise alignm... >>
View Comments (Flat Mode) Printer Version
Stonehenge Hidden Landscape Pr... There is an attachment here Simon - 26/11
    - Deleted User Account - 26/11
       - Deleted User Account - 26/11
          - Deleted User Account - 26/11
          Re: Stonehenge Hidden Landscap... Simon - 26/11
    More accurate data (Re: Stoneh... There is an attachment here Simon - 29/11
       Re: More accurate data (Re: St... Jon Morris - 1/12
          Re: More accurate data (Re: St... Simon - 1/12
             Re: More accurate data (Re: St... Jon Morris - 2/12